Issue:Including nested templates no longer works with MW 1.12's new parser behaviour
Description: | Including nested templates no longer works with MW 1.12's new parser behaviour |
Extension / Version: | DPL / 1.6.8 |
Type / Status: | Bug / open |
Contents
Problem
Including nested templates no longer works with MW 1.12's new parser behaviour.
Pre 1.12 behaviour
{{#dpl:title=Random|include={Template Name}:Parameter}}
Which until 1.12 outputted the contents of the field, even if it contained another (nested) template.
Article random contents
{{Template Name Parameter = {{Another Template|Something}} }}
Post 1.12 behaviour
{{#dpl:title=Random|include={Template Name}:Parameter}}
Now outputs:
{{Another Template|Something}} (Without parsing it)
Reply
This is surprising! As far as I understand the new MW parser version will never allow the kind of constructs you mention. http://svn.wikimedia.org/svnroot/mediawiki/tags/REL1_12_0RC1/phase3/RELEASE-NOTES contains a chapter on parser changes which states that the parsing sequence has intentionally been changed and now no longer supports the construction of template code by other templates.
Could somebody find out how to nest templates in future (regardless of DPL)? I think the developers of the MW parser should be told that they are going to cut down a useful behaviour. What alternative do they offer? I would be pleased if you could find out!
citation:
Uncovered preprocessor syntax is generally not recognised. For example, if you have "{{a" in Template:A and "b}}" in Template:B, then "{{a}}{{b}}" will be converted to a literal "{{ab}}" rather than the contents of Template:Ab. This was the case previously in HTML output mode, and is now uniformly the case in the other modes as well. HTML-style comments uncovered by template expansion will not be recognised by the preprocessor and hence will not prevent template expansion within them, but they will be stripped by the following HTML security pass
- Gero 08:07, 28 March 2008 (CET)